Call Us Today! 608-374-7355


Selling a home can be an overwhelming process. How much should you sell it for? What repairs does your home need? How should you prepare it for showing? How do you inspire interest in your property? At First Choice Realty, Inc., we help you navigate all of these areas. Our experienced agents have expertise in local real estate markets in Tomah, WI and the surrounding areas. We get results – making sure your property is sold quickly and at a fair price is our priority. We work with residential, commercial, and land properties.
Beautiful house with stone siding

We Help You Sell Your Property Quickly & at a Great Price!


Modern Marketing

To make sure your property is reaching as many people as possible, First Choice Realty, Inc. uses creative, proven marketing tools. We especially rely on social media marketing to ensure properties are reaching targeted audiences, giving you the best chance of finding great potential buyers.

Property Appraisal

We have a certified personal property appraiser on staff to help you set the right price for your home. We utilize comparative market analysis and have a thorough understanding of home values in the local markets. Our goal is to help you set a competitive price that will attract potential buyers, while ensuring the home isn’t being sold for less than what it is worth.


What is my property worth in today’s market?

Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.

Online Auctions

First Choice Realty, Inc. and Brandau & Hill Auctioneers have been revolutionizing real estate auctions for the past 15 years. We now offer online auctions, which help our residential sellers get offers the day of the auction and to close within 30 days at a fair market price. In fact, 95% of our residential properties are sold with the help of our online auctions! Plus, for those selling farm land, we are able to offer multi-parcels of land as a single sale to streamline the process for you.

Reach Out

Contact us today at 608-374-7355. We look forward to working with you and helping you find your dream property!

Check out our video testimonials! 


"Where would I be without Mary Jo at First Choice Realty? You expect a realtor to help with sales and purchases. Mary Jo is a realtor that went above and beyond in helping me with multiple transactions. She not only handled the sales, she helped guide me to legal steps needed to complete complicated transactions. Her honesty and integrity always assured me to trust her directions. If anyone is looking for a remarkable agent I would highly recommend working with Mary Jo Hill at First Choice Realty. Respectfully Shawn & Barbara Jacobson." - Barbara Jackson


"Mary Jo is one of those rare realtors that works very well for both the buyer and seller. Her experience also is an asset because she knows the market, the area and the pluses and minuses when looking for a home or property. We had some requests out of the ordinary when we were looking to buy our home and Mary Jo was great in negotiating everything with the seller. You are in good hands with First Choice Realty." -Steve Peterson


"I worked with a realtor from First Choice Realty Inc. to sell our home. From the very start I could tell that our realtor was very sincere. I had total confidence placing trust in her. She was extremely professional the whole time we worked together, yet incredibly caring of our feelings, wants and needs. I'd recommend First Choice Realty Inc. to anyone buying or selling a home." - April Taylor


"First Choice Realty is a great real estate company to help you manage to buy your very first home or your dream home. Mary jo Hill as my real estate agent helped me find my little hobby farm. I have worked with First Choice Realty for the past 7 years. Mary Jo Hill worked extensively and to the best of her ability within a very timely manner to find that perfect home for my family and I. I recommend FIRST CHOICE REALTY -MARY JO HILL. to anyone who is looking for their FIRST or their DREAM HOME" - Lori Woods 


"Once again we were able to rely on the services of Mary Jo. She is so amazing to work with and fully listens to her clients and what their wishes are. I would recommend her for all your home buying experiences." - Amy K.


"I couldn't have had a better experience buying a home, Mary Jo and Carol really got to know what exactly I was looking for in a home and found me the perfect home. I would recommend First Choice Realty to anyone buying a home in the area." - Anthony M.


"MaryJo and staff are great to work with! They helped us sell a family property through auction. Maryjo took us through every step of the process and made the auction of the property painless. I'm grateful for MaryJo and First Choice helping us to receive great value." - Stu L.


Phone: 608-374-7355
Fax: 608-374-3700


Monday – Friday
9:00 AM – 4:00 PM

Sorry we are experiencing system issues. Please try again.